AMIR TEMURNING DAVLAT BOSHQARUVI MASALALARI SOVET DAVRI TARIXSHUNOSLIGIDA: BAHOLAR VA YODNASHUVLAR

Tarix va tarixshunoslik

##article.authors##

  • Feruza Shamukaramova tarix fanlari doktori, katta ilmiy xodim O‘zbekiston Respublikasi Fanlar аkademiyasi Tarix instituti

##semicolon##

https://doi.org/10.66803/2026.1.182

##semicolon##

Amir Temur##common.commaListSeparator## Temuriylar##common.commaListSeparator## Movarounnahr##common.commaListSeparator## Turkiston##common.commaListSeparator## Markaziy Osiyo##common.commaListSeparator## davlat boshqaruvi##common.commaListSeparator## V.V. Bartold##common.commaListSeparator## A.Yu. Yakubovskiy##common.commaListSeparator## I.M. Muminov##common.commaListSeparator## O‘zbekiston tarixi##common.commaListSeparator## sovet davri##common.commaListSeparator## Samarqand

##article.abstract##

Maqola sovet davri tarixshunosligida Temur (1336–1405; hukmronlik yillari (1370–1405) va Temuriylar (1370–1507) davrining davlat boshqaruvi masalalariga berilgan baholarni manbashunoslik va tarixshunoslik yondashuvlar kesimida tahlil qiladi. V.V. Bartold, A.Yu. Yakubovskiy,
I.I. Umnyakov, I.M. Mo‘minov ishlarida markazlashgan davlat qurilishi, ma’muriy tizim, harbiy tashkilot, soliq va pul muomalasi, shaharsozlik hamda diplomatiya masalalariga yondashuvlar ko‘rsatilib, ularning sovet mafkurasi bosimi ta’sirida vaqt o‘tishi bilan qanday transformatsiyalangani yoritiladi. Metodologik asos sifatida tarixiylik va qiyosiy tahlil usullari qo‘llanib, 1950–1974-yillardagi akademik nashrlar va mavzuga doir alohida tadqiqotlar korpusida baholarning ideologik qayta talqinlari xaritalanadi. Natijalar sovet davrida Amir Temur shaxsiyati va boshqaruv tizimining ijobiy hamda salbiy jihatlari selektiv yoritilganini, ayniqsa iqtisodiy masalalar (er munosabatlari, soliq va b.) yetarlicha ishlanmaganini ko‘rsatadi. Xulosa qismida mustaqillikdan keyingi tadqiqotlar uchun ochiq qolgan yo‘nalishlar, jumladan, iqtisodiy-huquqiy institutlar va arxiv materiallari asosidagi empirik tadqiqotlar ustuvorligi asoslanadi.

##plugins.generic.usageStats.downloads##

##plugins.generic.usageStats.noStats##

##submission.citations##

Abduraimov, M. (1973). Obzor literaturi, posvyashennoy Timuru i Timuridam, izdannoy v Uzbekistane v 60-x godax. – Istoriya SSSR, № 5, 47–51. [Abduraimov, M. (1973). A Review of Literature on Timur and the Timurids, Published in Uzbekistan in the 1960s. – History of the USSR, No. 5, 47–51. (in Russian)]

Abidjanova, D.S. (2017). Istochniki po istorii perioda Amira Temura i Temuridov. Istoriografiya voprosa. / Istoriya Uzbekistana. Epoxa Amira Temura i Temuridov. Tashkent: Fan. – С. 16–42. [Abidzhanova, D.S. (2017). Sources on the History of the period of Amir Temur and the Temurids. Historiography of the Issue. / History of Uzbekistan. The Era of Amir Temur and the Temurids. Tashkent: Fan. – Pp. 16–42. (in Russian)].

Alimova, D.A. (2017). Problemы izucheniya istorii perioda Amira Temura i Temuridov v kontekste gosudarstvennosti. – «Temuriylar davrida ilm-fan va madaniyat» xalqaro ilmiy konferensiya tezislari. 2017 yil 13–14 sentyabr. Toshkent: Akademnashr. – S. 29–30. [Alimova, D.A. (2017).

The problems of studying the history of the period of Amir Temur and the Temurids in the context of statehood. “Abstracts of the International Scientific Conference ‘Science and Culture in the Timurid Era.’ September 13–14, 2017. Tashkent: Akademnashr. – Pp. 29–30. (in Russian)].

Amir Temur v mirovoy istorii. (2001). / Gotovili k izdaniyu: N. Xabibullaev, E. Rtveladze, A. Xakimov i dr. Tashkent: Shark. [Amir Temur in World History. (2001). / Prepared for publication by N. Khabibullaev, E. Rtveladze, A. Khakimov, and others. Tashkent: Sharq. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1901). Timur (Tamerlan). – Ensiklopedicheskiy slovar «Brokgauza-Yefron». T. XXXIII. SPb. – S. 193–197. [Barthold, V.V. (1901). Timur (Tamerlane). – Brockhaus-Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary. Vol. XXXIII. St. Petersburg. – Pp. 193–197. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1963a). Istoriya kulturnoy jizni Turkestana. – Sochineniya. Moskva. Tom II. Ch. I. – S. 169–433. [Barthold, V.V. (1963a). History of the cultural Life of Turkestan. – Works. Moscow. Vol. II. Part I. – Pp. 169–433. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1963b). Istoriya Turkestana (Konspekt leksiy po istorii Turkestana s drevneyshix vremen do zavoevaniya yego russkimi). Sochineniya. Moskva. T. II. Ch. 1. – S. 109–168. [Barthold, V.V. (1963b). History of Turkestan (Lecture notes on the history of Turkestan from ancient times to its conquest by the Russians). Works. Moscow. Vol. II. Part 1. – Pp. 109–168. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1963v). Mesto prikaspiyskix oblastey v istorii musulmanskogo mira. – Sochineniya. Moskva. T. II. Ch. 1. – S. 650–772. [Barthold, V.V. (1963c). The Place of the Caspian Regions in the History of the Muslim World. – Works. Moscow. Vol. II. Part 1. – Pp. 650–772. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1963g). Temur i Temuridi. Razdel VI. «Istorii Turkestana». – Sochineniya. Moskva. T. II. Ch. I. – S. 157–162. [Barthold, V.V. (1963g). Timur and the Timurids. Section VI. "Histories of Turkestan". – Works. Moscow. Vol. II. Part I. – Pp. 157–162. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1964a). Mir Ali-Shir i politicheskaya jizn. – Sochineniya. Moskva. T. II. Ch. 2. – S. 199–260. [Barthold, V.V. (1964a). Mir Ali-Shir and Political Life. – Works. Moscow. Vol. II. Part 2. – Pp. 199–260. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1964b). Ulugbek i yego vremya. – Sochineniya. Moskva. T. II. Ch. 2. – S. 23–196 (Sarstvovanie Timura). [Bartold, V.V. (1964b). Ulugh Beg and His Time. Works. Moscow: Nauka. Vol. II. Part 2. – Pp. 23–196 (Timur’s Reign). (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1966a). Kultura musulmanstva. – Sochineniya. Moskva. T. VI. – S. 141–204. [Barthold, V.V. (1966a). The Culture of Islam. Works. Moscow. Vol. VI. – Pp. 141–204. (in Russian).]

Bartold, V.V. (1966b). Moneti Ulugbeka. – Sochineniya. Moskva. T. IV. – S. 362–364. [Barthold, V.V. (1966b). Ulugh Beg’s Coins. Works. Moscow. Vol. IV. – Pp. 362–364. (in Russian)].

Bartold, V.V. (1968). Dvenadsat leksiy po istorii tyurskix narodov Sredney Azii (Leksiya XI–XII). Sochineniya. T. V. Moskva. – S. 169–182. [Barthold, V.V. (1968). Twelve lectures on the history of the Turkic peoples of Central Asia (Lectures XI–XII). Works. Vol. V. Moscow.

– Pp. 169–182. (in Russian)].

Bibliograficheskiy ukazatel. (2001). – Amir Temur v mirovoy istorii. Tashkent: Shark. – S. 261–282. [Bibliographic Index. (2001). – Amir Temur in World history. Tashkent: Sharq. – Pp. 261–282. (in Russian)].

Vaxabov, M.G. (1988). O pravde – tolko pravda. – Pravda Vostoka. 21 iyunya. [Vakhabov, M.G. (1988). About the truth – Only the truth. – Pravda Vostoka. June 21. (in Russian)].

Voprosi istorii. 1975. № 8. [Questions of History. 1975. No. 8. (in Russian)].

Istoriografiya epoxi Amira Temura. – Amir Temur v mirovoy istorii. Tashkent: Shark, 2001. – S. 189–210. [Historiography of the Era of Amir Temur. – Amir Temur in World History. Tashkent: Sharq, 2001. – Pp. 189–210. (in Russian)].

Istoriya Samarkanda. (1969). V dvux tomax. T. 1. Tashkent: Fan. [History of Samarkand. (1969). In two volumes. Vol. 1. Tashkent: Fan. (in Russian)].

Istoriya Uzbekskoy SSR. (1955). T. I. Kniga pervaya. Tashkent: Izd-vo AN UzbSSR. [History of the Uzbek SSR. (1955). Vol. I. Book One. Tashkent: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the Uzbek SSR. (in Russian)].

Istoriya Uzbekskoy SSR. (1955). T. I. Kniga pervaya. Tashkent: Izd-vo AN UzbSSR. [History of the Uzbek SSR. (1955). Vol. I. Book One. Tashkent: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the Uzbek SSR. (in Russian)].

Istoriya Uzbekskoy SSR. (1967). T. I. Tashkent: Fan. [History of the Uzbek SSR. (1967). Vol. I. Tashkent: Fan. (in Russian)]

Istoriya Uzbekskoy SSR. (1974). S drevneyshix vremen do nashix dney. Tashkent: Fan. [History of the Uzbek SSR. (1974). From ancient times to the present day. Tashkent: Fan. (in Russian)].

Lunin, B.V. (1969). Istoriya, kultura i iskusstvo vremeni timuridov v sovetskoy literature (Bibliograficheskiy ukazatel). – Obshestvennыe nauki v Uzbekistane. № 8–9. – S. 101–145. [Lunin, B.V. (1969). History, culture, and art of the Timurid era in Soviet literature (Bibliographic index). – Social sciences in Uzbekistan, No. 8–9, 101–145. (in Russian)].

Lunin, B.V. (1996). Amir Temur va uning davriga oid manbalar. – Temur va Ulug‘bek davri tarixi. Toshkent: Qomuslar bosh tahririyati. – B. 230–264. [Lunin, B.V. (1996). Sources on Amir Temur and his era. – History of the era of Temur and Ulugbek. Tashkent: Main editorial office of dictionaries. – Pp. 230–264. (in Uzbek)].

Lunin, B.V. (1996). Temur va uning davri tarixini o‘rganishga oid asosiy manbalar. Temur va uning davri haqida ilmiy adabiyotlar. Folklordagi Temur obrazi. Badiiy adabiyotlarda Temur tavsifi. Temur qiyofasini yaratish masalalari. – Temur va Ulug‘bek davri tarixi. Toshkent: Qomuslar bosh tahririyati. – B. 13–50. [Lunin, B.V. (1996). Main sources for studying the history of Temur and his era. Scientific literature about Temur and his era. The image of Temur in folklore. Description of Temur in fiction. Issues of creating the image of Temur. – History of the era of Temur and Ulugbek. Tashkent: Main editorial office of dictionaries. – Pp. 13–50. (in Uzbek)].

Masson, M.E. (1941). Observatoriya Ulugbeka. Tashkent: Fan. [Masson, M.E. (1941). Ulugh Beg Observatory. Tashkent: Fan (in Russian)].

Muminov, I.M. (1968). Rol i mesto Amira Timura v istorii Sredney Azii. V svete dannыx pismennix istochnikov. Tashkent: Fan. [Muminov, I.M. (1968). The role and place of Amir Timur in the history of Central Asia. In the light of written sources. Tashkent: Fan. (in Russian)].

Novoselsev, A.P. (1973). Ob istoricheskoy otsenke Timura. – Voprosi istorii, № 2, 3–20. [Novosel'tsev, A.P. (1973). On the historical assessment of Timur. – Questions of History. No. 2. – Pp. 3–20. (in Russian)].

Pugachenkova G.A. (1950). Samarkandskaya keramika XV veka. – Trudi SAGU. Vip. XI. Tashkent. – S. 91–120. [Pugachenkova G.A. (1950). Samarkand ceramics of the 15th century. – The works of SAGU. Vol. XI. Tashkent. – S. 91–120. (in Russian)].

Raxmatullaeva A.R. (2010). Istoriografiya jizni i deyatelnosti Amira Temura v Uzbekistane (1991 – 2009). Avtoreferat dissertatsii na soiskanie uchenoy stepeni kandidata istoricheskix nauk. Tashkent. [Rakhmatullaeva A.R. (2010). Historiography of the Life and Work of Amir Temur in Uzbekistan (1991–2009). Abstract of a Dissertation for the Degree of Candidate of Historical Sciences. Tashkent. (in Russian)]. Rtveladze, E.V., Alimova, D.A. (2016). Issledovatelskie podxodi k istorii epoxi Temura i Temuridov (prinsipi raboti nad kollektivnoy monografiey). – Temuriylar davri yozma merosining tarqalishi va o‘rganilishi. VIII Respublika ilmiy-amaliy konferensiyasi materiallari. Toshkent: Mashhurpress.

– S. 6–11. [Rtveladze, E.V., Alimova, D.A. (2016). Research Approaches to the History of the Era of Temur and the Temurids (Principles of Working on a Collective Monograph). – The spread and study of the written heritage of the Timurid period. Materials of the VIII Republican Scientific and Practical Conference. Tashkent: Mashhurpress. – P. 6–11. (in Russian)].

Snesarev, A.E. (1923). Russkiy Vostok kak zadacha kraevednogo izucheniya. – V kn.: Voprosы kraevedeniya. Nijniy Novgorod. – S. 159–171. Kak otdelnaya statya pereizdano v jurnale «Vostok». 1993. № 3. http://www.snesarev.ru/trudi/russkiy_vostok.html. [Snesarev, A.E. (1923). The Russian East as a Task of Local History Study. – In the book: Questions of Local History. Nizhny Novgorod. – P. 159–171. Republished as a separate article in the journal "Vostok". 1993. No. 3. http://www.snesarev.ru/trudi/russkiy_vostok.html. (in Russian)].

Trever K.V., Yakubovskiy A.Yu., Vorones M.E. Istoriya narodov Uzbekistana. (1950). T. I. S drevneyshix vremen do nachala XVI veka. Tashkent: Izd-vo AN UzSSR. [Trever K.V., Yakubovsky A.Yu., Voronets M.E. History of the Peoples of Uzbekistan. (1950). Vol. I. From Ancient times to the beginning of the 16th century. Tashkent: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the Uzbek SSR. (in Russian)].

Tumanovich, N.N. (1976). Opisanie arxiva V. V. Bartolda. Moskva: Glavnaya redaksiya Vostochnoy literaturi. – S. 233–467. [Tumanovich, N.N. (1976). Description of the Archive of V.V. Bartold. Moscow: Main Editorial Board of Eastern Literature. – P. 233–467. (in Russian)].

Uljaeva Sh.M. (1999). Istoriografiya epoxi Amira Temura i Temuridov 50 – 60-x godov XX veka (na primere literaturi sovetskogo perioda). Avtoreferat dissertatsii na soiskanie uchenoy stepeni kandidata istoricheskix nauk. Tashkent. – 27 s. [Ulzhaeva Sh.M. (1999). Historiography of the Era of Amir Temur and the Temurids of the 1950s–1960s (Based on the Literature of the Soviet Period). Abstract of a dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Historical Sciences. Tashkent. – 27 p. (in Russian)].

Umnyakov, I.I. (1956). Mejdunarodnie otnosheniya Sredney Azii v nachale XV veka. Snosheniya Timura s Vizantiey i Fransiey.– Trudi Uzbekskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im Alishera Navoi. Vip. 61. Samarkand. – S. 179–200. [Umnyakov, I.I. (1956). International Relations of Central Asia at the Beginning of the 15th Century. Timur's Relations with Byzantium and France.– Transactions of the Alisher Navoi Uzbek State University. Issue 61. Samarkand. – Pp. 179–200. (in Russian)].

Umnyakov, I.I. (1960). Iz istorii mejdunarodnix otnosheniy Sredney Azii s Zapadnoy Yevropoy v nachale XV v. – Izvestiya AN UzSSR. Seriya obщestvennix nauk. Tashkent. № 1. – S. 27–33. [Umnyakov, I.I. (1960). From the history of International Relations of Central Asia with Western Europe at the Beginning of the 15th Century. – Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Uzbek SSR. Social Sciences Series. Tashkent. No. 1. – Pp. 27–33. (in Russian)].

Umnyakov, I.I. (1976). Annotirovannaya bibliografiya trudov V.V.Bartolda. Moskva: Glavnaya redaksiya Vostochnoy literatury. – S. 8–229. [Umnyakov, I.I. (1976). Annotated Bibliography of

V.V. Barthold's Works. Moscow: The main editorial office of Eastern literature. – P. 8–229. (in Russian)].

Usmonov B.A. (2004) Amir Temur hayoti va davlatchilik faoliyatining Rossiya tarixshunosligida yoritilishi (XVIII–XX asrlar). Tarix fanlari nomzodi ilmiy darajasini olish uchun dissertatsiya avtoreferati. Toshkent. [Usmonov B. A. (2004) Coverage of the life and state activities of Amir Temur in Russian historiography (18th – 20th centuries). Abstract of the dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Historical Sciences. Tashkent. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1925). Obrazi starogo Samarkanda (Vremya Timura). – Vostok. Kn. 5. Moskva-Leningrad. – S. 140–163. Yakubovsky, A. Yu. (1925). Images of old Samarkand (The Time of Timur). – Vostok. Book 5. Moscow-Leningrad. – P. 140–163. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1932). Feodalnoe obshestvo Sredney Azii i yego torgovlya s Vostochnoy Yevropoy v X – XV vv. – Materialы poistorii Uzbekskoy, Tadjikskoy i Turkmenskoy SSR. Chast 1. Leningrad. – S. 1-60. [Yakubovsky, A. Yu. (1932). Feudal society of Central Asia and its trade with Eastern Europe in the 10th – 15th centuries. – Materials on the history of the Uzbek, Tajik, and Turkmen SSR. Part 1. Leningrad. – Pp. 1-60 (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1933). Samarkand pri Timure i Timuridax. Leningrad. [Yakubovsky, A. Yu. (1933). Samarkand under Timur and the Timurids. Leningrad. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1939). Mastera Irana v Sredney Azii pri Timure. – V kn.: Iranskoe iskusstvo i arxeologiya. III Mejdunarodniy kongress po iranskomu iskusstvu i arxeologii. Dokladы. Moskva–Laningrad, 1939. – S. 277–285. [Yakubovsky, A. Yu. (1939). Masters of Iran in Central Asia under Timur. – In: Iranian Art and Archaeology. III International Congress on Iranian Art and Archaeology. Papers. Moscow–Lanigrad, 1939. – Pp. 277–285. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1946). Timur (opit kratkoy xarakteristiki) – Voprosi istorii. № 8–9. – S. 42–74. [Yakubovsky, A. Yu. (1946). Timur (an attempt at a brief characterization) – Questions of History. No. 8–9. – Pp. 42–74. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1947). Iz istorii padeniya Zolotoy Ordi. – Voprosi istorii. № 2. – S. 30–45. [Yakubovsky, A.Yu. (1947). From the History of the Fall of the Golden Horde. – Questions of History. No. 2. – Pp. 30–45. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1950). Padenie Zolotoy Ordi. – V kn.: Grekov B.D., Yakubovskiy A.Yu. Zolotaya Orda i yee padenie. Moskva-Leningrad. (Glava «Borba Timura i Toxtamisha v 80-x godax XIV veka»). – S. 216–428. [Yakubovsky, A.Yu. (1950). The Fall of the Golden Horde. In: Grekov, B.D., Yakubovsky, A.Yu. The Golden Horde and Its Fall. (Chapter "The Struggle between Timur and Tokhtamysh in the 1380s"). Moscow-Leningrad. – Pp. 216–428. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu. (1953). Srednyaya Aziya v XIII – XV vv. – Ocherki istorii SSSR. Period feodalizma. Ch. II. Moskva: Izd-vo AN SSSR. – S. 648–679. [Yakubovsky, A. Yu. (1953). Central Asia in the 13th–15th Centuries. Essays on the History of the USSR. The Period

of Feudalism. Part II. Moscow: Publishing House of the USSR Academy of Sciences.

– Pp. 648–679. (in Russian)].

Yakubovskiy, A.Yu., Petrushevskiy, I.P. (1957). Obrazovanie gosudarstva Timura. Poxodi Timura i yego vnutrennyaya politika. Iran pod vladыchestvom Timura i timuridov. – Vsemirnaya istoriya. T. III. Moskva. Gl. XXXVII. – S. 572–587. [Yakubovsky, A.Yu., Petrushevsky, I.P. (1957). Formation of Timur's State. Timur's Campaigns and His Domestic Policy. Iran under the rule of Timur and the Timurids. World History. Vol. III. Moscow. Ch. XXXVII. – P. 572–587. (in Russian)].

##submission.downloads##

##submissions.published##

2026-06-30

##issue.issue##

##section.section##

Articles