АL-BIRUNI’S CONTRIBUTION AND LEADING ROLE TO HISTORICAL CRITICISM IN ISLAMIC HISTORIOGRAPHY

Authors

  • Mustafo Demirci

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.66803/2024.2.6

Keywords:

Biruni,, Criticism, Verification,, Methodology,, Historiography.

Abstract

 Abu’r-Rayhan al-Biruni, who lived in the period and region when the
Islamic world was most productive in terms of science (10th century –
Khwarezm), is one of the greatest divan in the history of science. Biruni
produced works by bringing together many different fields such as geology,
history, physics, mathematics, astronomy, geography, geology and geodesy,
medicine, pharmacy, and philosophy in his mental world. He methodically
criticized, verified, and revealed the errors of all the information he
received. Thanks to his intelligence, observation skills, the way he handled
information, systematic criticism (criticism) and examination method
(tahkiq), his views have maintained their validity until today. By skillfully
using the experimental method in natural sciences, the “mathematical
proof” method in fields such as astronomy and geography, and the criticism
and verification method in social sciences, he successfully combined
natural sciences with human sciences in the mental world and reached
original results.
His scientific pioneers are Abu Yaqub Ishak al-Kindi and Abu Bakr
Zakariyya al-Razi. He carried out all these scientific activities as a sincere
Muslim, even with the support of the Islamic faith. Biruni was the first to
use the concept of "human sciences". He carried out pioneering studies in
many areas of social sciences. Focusing on humans and analyzing their
relationships with existence, knowledge and the natural world, he pioneered
modern anthropology; and critical historiography by reading history,
religions and philosophies from a realistic and critical perspective. In
Biruni's works, we see the scientific perspective of a contemporary
scientist

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bruce R. Reichenbach. Introduction to Critical Thinking USA:

Library of Congress, 2001.

Dani Ahmef Hasan. Alberuni's Indica: A record of the cultural history

of South Asia about A.D. 1030. University of Islamabad Press,

Islamabad, 1979.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî, Tahkîk-u Mâ li'l u Mâ li'l

u Mâ li'l-Hind min Makûletin Hind min Makûletin Makbûletin fî Akli

ev Merzûle. / Tahkîk, Eduard Sachau, Makbuletin fî Akli ev Merzûle,

Ed. Fuat Sezgin. London, 1887.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. Beruni's India. /

Translated by Edward C. Sachau, Edit, Fuat Sezgin. London, 1910.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. İstihraci'l-Evtar, Fi

Dairatu. / Tahkîk, Ahmet Said Demirtas. Cairo, 1965.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. Kitâbü'l-Cemâhir fî Ma’rifeti’l

Cemâhir / Translated by Emine Sonnur Özcan). Ankara, 2017.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. Makâle fî Hakayeti Ehli’lHind fî İstihrâci’l Umr / Published. Z. V. Togan, Islamic Studies Institute

Journal Supplement, Islamic Studies Institute Journal Supplement,

Islamic Studies Institute Journal Supplement. Istanbul, 1954.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. Tahdîd Nihâyât

Al-Âmâkın li Tashih Masâfât Âmâkın li Tashih Masâfât Al-Masâkın /

Translated by Kivameddin Burslan. Ankara, 2015.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. Tahdîd Nihâyâti’l-Emâkin

li Tashîhi Emakin li Tashîhi Mesâfâti'l- Mesâfâti'l-Mesâkin, Mesâkin

and Neşr. Muhammed Tavid Tanci, Tahdîd Nihâyâti'l-Emâkin li

Tashîhi Emakin li Tashîhi Mesâfâti'l. Ankara, 1962.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed Birûnî. The Chronology, The

Chronology of Ancient Nations, The Chronology of Ancient Nations /

Translated by y of Ancient Nations, Eduard Sachau. Frankfurt, 1984.

Ebû Reyhan Muhammed b. Ahmed. Âsâru'l-Bâkıye ani'l Bâkıye ani'l

Bâkıye ani'l-Kurûni’l Hâliye Kurûni'l Hâliye. / Tahkîk, Eduard

Sachau, trc. Ahsen Batur. Istanbul, 2011.

Franz Rosenthal. On Some of Beyruni’s Presuppositions Regarding

the Theory and Method of Knowledge / Translated by Prof. Dr.

Mübahat Türker Küyel, Biruniye Armağan. Ankara, 1974.

Mustafa Lebib Аbdulgina. Dirasata Fi Philosophy'l-'lm'Indel Biruni.

Cairo, 1996.

Seyyit Hüseyin Nasr. İslam Kozmoloji. Öğretilerine Giriş Istanbul, 1985.

Vincent Ryan Ruggiero. Becoming a Critical Thinker. USA: Library

of Congress, 2002.

Walzer Richard. Greek Into Arabic, University of South Carolina Press, 1970.

Yumna Tarif Havli. Buhus Fi Historyul Ulum ‘Indel ‘Arab, London, 2018.

Zeki Velidi Togan. "The Conception of Tankidi in the Medieval

Islamic World" in The Islam Tetkikleri Institutesü Dergisi / Еdit. by

Zeki Velidi Togan, I, parts 1–4 (1953), (Istanbul, 1954 (Eng.

Translation: "The Concept of Critical Historiography In The Islamic

World Of The Middle Ages" Islamic Studies, Autumn 1975, Vol. 14,

No. 3 (Autumn 1975).

Downloads

Published

2024-12-31 — Updated on 2026-03-24

Issue

Section

Articles